By Jayson Blair
Sandy and Christopher Carlson made an offer
late last year on a $460,000 one-bedroom loft in the East
Village before they had even walked in the door. The Carlsons,
who lived in Los Angeles, were looking for a pied-a-terre
in New York but did not want to cross the continent each
time a broker called.
Because waiting is not an option in the
Manhattan real estate market, they took a tour of another
kind -- on the Internet -- looking at floor plans and photographs
sent by e-mail and taking virtual tours on a Web site.
''I had never been inside,'' Mrs. Carlson said in a recent
telephone interview from Los Angeles before her move. ''I
just couldn't afford to fly back there every time I heard
of something that interested me, and I couldn't afford to
stop work for three months and just look out there. So,
the Internet was perfect.''
More and more, prospective home buyers
and renters are window shopping by computer.
This is particularly true in the New York
market, where listings disappear so fast that waiting for
the Sunday classifieds can be risky. It also permits house-hunters
to view a potential home before even contacting a broker.
The changes are being hailed by customers
and most real estate brokerages, but have drawn concern
from some individual brokers. They fear that the dot-coms
will cut into their business or even make them superfluous,
in a world where potential clients could use the Web to
contact sellers directly, bypassing brokers.
Web real estate shopping has also spawned
its own subcultures, from the prospective renters who check
The Village Voice online at 12:01 a.m. five nights a week
(when the Web site posts its new listings) to those who
take virtual tours and look at the floor plans of luxury
apartments and buildings on DouglasElliman.com.
Nationwide, there were more than 3 million
homes advertised on the Web in April, compared with the
more than 2.4 million listed each month in other places,
like classified advertisements.
Analysts say that unlike many new Web ventures,
which have high startup costs and low revenues, some real
estate sites have already found a way to become profitable
by taking a percentage of sale commissions.
Most of the New York real estate sites
are run by brokerages, but a handful -- like www.mlx.com,
which allows anyone, not just brokers, to list properties
-- are independent companies that have begun to move into
the market. These companies make money by charging anyone
who wants to browse their listings. Some others charge small
fees, much lower than standard sales commissions, for listing
a property.
''A lot of Internet companies have a hard
time making money because they are trying to reinvent the
wheel,'' said Tan Chan, the chief financial officer of Corcoran.com,
the site where the Carlsons recently bought their apartment.
Corcoran.com has spun off from the Corcoran
Group, the real estate brokerage, and will soon move into
offices in SoHo. The new company plans to make money by
allowing affiliate brokerages worldwide to list real estate
on its site. Corcoran.com will receive 25 percent of the
commission on any sales that come from its leads, said James
W. Kim, the chief executive.
Barbara Corcoran, the president of the
Corcoran Group and the chairwoman of both companies, began
the Web site with plain text listings in 1994, at a time
when the information superhighway was much less traveled.
But over the next three years, brokers -- some of whom were
not even using e-mail -- began getting calls from clients
interested in listings they saw on the Web site.
Since then, Ms. Corcoran has added features
like floor plans and a database that allows prospective
buyers and renters to search for properties with certain
amenities, in specific neighborhoods and within their price
range. She has also added photographs, e-mail links to brokers
and 3-D virtual tours. Corcoran.com, which unveiled its
new Web site in April, has in many ways been way ahead of
the curve, according to online real estate industry experts.
Last year, the company received 28,879
e-mail requests and sold 225 apartments to clients who came
through the Web site. In recent weeks, the Web site has
seen up to 7,500 visitors a day. In New York, selling a
home on the Internet can cost a company less than $1 in
advertising, compared with hundreds of dollars per sale
using the classifieds, company officials said.
For now, there is little worry among those
working in newspaper advertising that sales of classifieds
will decline because of online real estate sales. The reason
is that real estate companies still need to use classifieds,
as well as television spots and display advertisements,
to draw customers to their Web pages.
But these transformations have already
given pause to some brokers who are worried that the online
companies are cutting into their commissions.
Information that brokers once provided
-- Is this a good neighborhood? Is this a realistic price
for a two-bedroom in this area? How do I finance a mortgage
on this apartment? -- is increasingly available on Web sites.
Rolf T. Wigand, director of the Center
for Digital Commerce at Syracuse University, said brokers
''are trying to find their new role in this process'' because
customers can ''partially bypass'' them.
Robert G. Eychner, founder of Eychner Associates,
a downtown real estate brokerage, said: ''Everyone has to
be on the Internet one way or the other. But there is no
replacing the human aspect of having a broker, especially
in today's heated market. A computer can't tell you that
this is a brand new listing and that it is going to last
20 minutes.''
Mr. Eychner, whose company has been selling
in New York since 1982, said part of his job description
is being a therapist. ''Buying residential real estate,
people really need to talk it through and they need to have
someone holding their hand, an adviser who has been through
the process,'' Mr. Eychner added. ''There is no computer
that is going to help you with a co-op board.''
Mr. Eychner has encouraged his brokers
to set up Web pages at the company's site, www.eychner.com,
but sees them more limitedly as tools to attract people,
particularly international clients.
And Benita Cohen, an independent real estate
broker in Gramercy Park for more than 20 years, said the
Internet has disadvantages for clients and brokers. Buyers,
she said, will often see things on the Internet that are
not realistic for them -- and that brokers would not have
typically shown them -- and time is often wasted on the
properties.
In addition, Ms. Cohen said the Internet
would never be an effective tool for the most high-end customers.
''There are properties that never make it out on the Internet,
that brokers only hear about over lunch, especially in an
insanely competitive market like this,'' she said. ''There
is stuff that walks off the table before you could turn
on your computer.''
Ms. Corcoran hopes brokers will be willing
to give up some of their commissions if Web sites bring
additional clients. She also says the Web, by educating
buyers about what is available, can cut down on the amount
of time the agents have to spend with clients.
Mr. Wigand, the professor and expert on
New York's online real estate community, said that because
of the exposure the Internet offers brokers on the Web ''sell
more and quicker.''
While Corcoran.com has been a leader among
New York real estate companies, almost every major brokerage
in the city has a Web site with listings, floor plans and
other similar features.
One benefit the Web sites offer is speed.
And the Carlsons, who are builders, took advantage of it.
Mrs. Carlson flew to New York to look for
an apartment last fall after her broker found a one-bedroom
loft apartment in TriBeCa. Mrs. Carlson visited the apartment
and took pictures for her husband. She returned home and
made an offer, but was beaten out by a higher bid.
Mrs. Carlson decided she was not going
to let that happen again, and began checking New York real
estate Web sites. In early December, she clicked onto Corcoran.com
and found another apartment she liked. She called her broker,
and asked him to visit the apartment -- at Avenue A and
Houston Street -- and take digital pictures that could be
sent by e-mail.
The next day, after speaking with her husband,
Mrs. Carlson made an offer and it was accepted. ''Normally,
I would never consider buying a place without seeing it,''
Mrs. Carlson explained. ''But it is really helpful in the
New York market.''
The Carlsons have moved into the apartment,
and say that the virtual visit lived up to the real thing.